The murky water surrounding Australia’s sharks

While the new plan to cull sharks in Western Australia seems for itself very controversial, things get worse if one considers the context. A closer look at the facts confirms that fishery management and law enforcement might not be nearly as good as generally perceived.

No question, it would be nice to reduce the risk of humans being attacked by sharks (or any other animal) to zero in order for us to enjoy every single corner of the planet to its fullest. Yet, does that match with other goals such as biodiversity conservation and species or habitat protection?
It’s obvious that we can’t have both; maximal biodiversity and the freedom to use nature as a safe playground for us humans. Confronted with a choice between both, should we really ignore current legislation[1] and kill rare and for the ecosystem important species to “improve public safety”. Mr Buswell’s argument “the preservation of human life is our number one priority” seems convincing and citizens are likely to applaud for his efforts to protect them. However, I doubt that the plan will achieve the apparent goal.

Firstly, there is the question of effectiveness of this plan. One doesn’t have to be an expert to understand that “setting baited drum lines” wasn’t the best idea to keep sharks away from attacking humans. To my understanding, “setting bait” will have the opposite effect of mitigating attacks. WA authorities are probably aware of it as well and consequently the plan for “faster, more aggressive response after attacks with more vessels“.

Secondly, the harshness (and likely costs) of the measures seem to stand in no relation to the risk. In 2012 there were 14 unprovoked and 8 provoked encounters between humans and sharks in waters around the country, resulting in 14 injuries and 2 fatalities (for humans). Compared with transport fatalities (35 killed cyclists, 194 killed pedestrians and 1477 total fatalities in 2009) this number seems extremely low. While it is estimated that at least one in four fatal road accidents is caused by elevated alcohol levels (above the legal BAC limit of 0.05) and knowing that a large number of us still drive after drug (incl. alcohol) use, the idea suggests itself that killing sharks to increase public safety seems to be completely displaced. Better law enforcement on roads could safe much more lives within a year than those lost due to shark attacks over history!

Finally, the proposed measures are totally out of proportion from a shark protection perspective. While, in an attempt to stop overfishing of many shark populations around the world, Western NGOs have made huge campaigns to reduce the consumption of shark fins in Asian countries with very positive echoes in Hong Kong, China and other Asian cities and countries, nobody seems to care about shark finning in Australia, not even NGOs[2]. According to ABARES 261.5 tons of shark fins and 505.3 tons of shark meat were being imported to Australia in 2012 alone!
Given little to no control over where the products come from, it is quite likely that at least part of the products come from very poorly managed fisheries in South Africa and Peru, where recent articles have revealed the brutality of this business. While we are constantly being told that Australian fisheries are among the best managed in the world, we forget that at least 75% of the seafood we eat are imports, most of it lacking proper traceability, contributing to overfishing, human rights abuse and environmental degradation in the countries of origin.

All in all, it is more likely that with the new shark plan WA’s authorities seek to gain voters’ support rather than to increase “public safety”. If they were honest, they would inform us that the best “Tool Kit” to protect communities was still common sense and not the meaningless slaughtering of sharks. However, honesty is not what wins elections these days and we all prefer to believe what sounds good while ignoring reality than to look at the often simple but disturbing facts of life.

[1] Targeted species such as the Great White Shark are protected under the EPBC Act

[2] I don’t remember having seen campaigns against the consumption of shark fins in Australia or any other Western country.


About blaubear

Born in 1973 in a small village in rural Switzerland and into a society largely dominated by cows (not only was the human population of one-hundred-and-forty outnumbered by them, but politics were driven by unreasonable subsidies for diary products) I was connected with nature from early age on. Observing nature on one hand and the deficiencies of a dysfunctional Swiss agricultural policy with farmers that had lost connection to the land that provided their income on the other, I soon started to question society and the meaning of life. Suffering also under a farcical public education I developed curiosity to discover on my own. That was how I soon learned that little of what I had been taught was true. Skepticism and interaction with people from for me new cultures fostered my interest for the world and eagerness to leave a life shaped by federalistic layman-ship. At the age of twenty-three I hit the road for the first time, an event that later translated into passion. Traveling between cultures has since become part of my life. At the age of thirty-three I finally realized my dream and did a degree in Environmental Engineering from which I graduated in 2009, only to leave Switzerland once more for my "real home" Spain. Unfortunately, the stay was a short one: a couple of months later I was offered a job in Southeast Asia, where I worked and also lived (with some interruptions, e.g. I live in Melbourne since late 2012) ever since. Having worked for a Japanese company earlier in my life, I soon felt captured again by Asian culture and thinking which makes a lovely contrast to my European heritage. My journey through different countries and cultures has taught me that regardless of how different our thinking and values are, no matter what approaches we take, we all can learn from each other. And if we are open enough to see the common instead of pointing out the differences, then we have a chance to live in harmony and peace: Life is all about integration, not exclusion! It's an old wisdom that "knowledge is power", as such I never get tired of being around new people, having interesting talks, and reading lots of good books. I hope that my blog can contribute to the conversation.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to The murky water surrounding Australia’s sharks

  1. Pingback: Shark culling and senate elections in WA – why details matter | Ideas for a greener environment, a fairer society and a future driven by sustainability

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s